Where is the vent of short video? Pear video is probably not.

At the beginning of this year, I communicated with my colleagues. Everyone thought that this year was the year of short video. Unexpectedly, it was live broadcast, which was embarrassing …

By the end of the year, the live broadcast is almost on fire. Hey, the short video limelight has come up again.

As it happens, I am also a short video practitioner, doing a car evaluation program. Let’s talk about this so-called tuyere. Please read it patiently and you will get some experience.

There are two landmark events in the recent short video:

There’s nothing to say about technology, it’s not new. Although xiaokaxiu was popular for a while, it quickly declined. After all, it is a minority demand and it is difficult to achieve great success. Secondshot is backed by Sina Weibo, but it has shown a decline. The traffic comes from Weibo to a large extent, and the user activity of Secondshot platform itself is not too high.

Not only the second shot, but also the king’s beautiful shot of short video, which is going downhill, so this year it began to transform into a live broadcast. Of the original short video platforms, only Aauto Quicker, which everyone thinks is very low, is not bad, and the number of users has increased, so their attitude towards live broadcast is relatively conservative. Although they have tried, they have not pushed it.

In this case, why do you say that this year is the slogan of short videos?

Two levels.

One is the platform.News clients such as today’s headlines and Netease News have entered the short video field, and they have put videos in a prominent position, like today’s headlines in the first-level entrance. These news clients bring huge traffic, and also stimulate the growth of short video content, which in turn feeds back the platform and improves user activity.

Not long ago, Zhang Yiming declared:

Today’s headlines began to enter this market in May last year. At present, we have 1 billion broadcasts every day, and video has surpassed graphics and pictures, becoming our largest content genre. Among them, 93% of the videos are less than 10 minutes, and 74% of the videos are less than 5 minutes. Today’s headlines have become the largest short video platform in China, and there is no one.

Domineering enough? From the feelings of content creators, Zhang Yiming is not bragging. We are doing a short car video program "Here comes the old driver". The single episode of the video has a maximum of more than 3 million headlines and more than 8,000 comments. Since it was launched in August, five videos have been played more than 500,000 times.

Today’s headlines, Youku, Tencent video, Station A, bilibili, UC headlines, a little information, Netease News, Iqiyi, Beijing time … The short car video program I am doing is distributed in more than ten channels, but no traffic can catch the headlines. I believe that most video creators have this feeling, which is not the characteristic of our family.

The second level of the short video outlet is: the content IP is popular., such as papi sauce, one, two more. In fact, in many segments, short video projects are also sought after by investors, and "30 seconds to understand the car", which focuses on cars, has won 15 million pre-A rounds of financing. Walking on this road in online celebrity, there are Chen Xiang, Ronaldinho and others.

After understanding these backgrounds, let’s look at the pear video.

Perhaps because many founding members come from the media, pear video is very good at promoting and creating momentum, and the media exposure rate is very high.

It looks quite powerful. The starting point of pear video is short information video. Judging from the data, this incision is undoubtedly correct.Because of the pursuit of hot spots, information short videos can get large traffic whether on social media or news clients.

But don’t be too happy, this kind of news flow is not too sticky.The short video like "Alarming People’s Daily", although the traffic is really high, is essentially the traffic of People’s Daily Weibo, not the pear video itself, so it is difficult to turn it into attention or download the pear video.

As a short video practitioner, I have been watching Pear Video since it was launched on November 3rd. Although there are frequent explosions and media bombings, frankly speaking, I am not optimistic.

Because there is something wrong with the positioning of pear video.

Is it a platform or a content producer? The pear video is vacillating.

On the one hand, pear video has recruited hundreds of people to be professional PGC, claiming to launch hundreds of videos a day and distribute them all over the network. Why do you want to do this? Pear video says that the lack of high-quality and fast original information videos can fill the gap.

On the other hand, pear video tried to focus on its own app, hoping that pear video app could be a short video distribution platform, so pear video recruited thousands of photographers from the beginning to stimulate UGC production.

These two moves look right, but they are all wrong.

From the perspective of content IP, PGC’s information short videos may be popular, but they are not sticky and personalized, so it is difficult to create a content IP with "online celebrity-fans" as the core.

Like the pear Video promotion mentioned above, its first-hand video has a monthly traffic of 6000W in Netease, but actually it has only saved 18,000 fans. One-handed Video is on Sina(second shot)It has been in operation for five months, with hundreds of millions of broadcasts, but there are only 200,000 fans in Weibo, and many reviews in Weibo are only single digits.

Pear video has also been running in Weibo for 20 days, and Changzhou video of unannounced visits to child labor has been forwarded by nearly 20,000 people, but there are still only 50,000 fans in Weibo. The WeChat of Pear Video may be less. In recent days, the number of single articles read is only one or two thousand, while there are hundreds of employees of Pear Video …

Of course there is nothing wrong with PGC, but it is not enough to just send information. When people eat eggs, they seldom care about the hens that lay eggs. My suggestion to the pear video is-personify, let everyone remember the hen. What the fans of "Runaway Comics" remember is Wang Nima who wears a hood.

Let’s talk about the second move of pear video, and make a short video distribution platform.

It should be said that if Qiu Bing rushes into short videos like this, he is definitely not satisfied with making a papi sauce. If he can be a platform, he must be a platform. Then let’s take a look at some data of the pear video app in the past 20 days:

Pear video first appeared in Baidu mobile assistant, which should be a good recommendation resource, with 210,000 downloads in 20 days. I can only say that it is not bad, not explosive.

Because Kuchuan hasn’t added pear video yet, I have roughly looked at the downloads of several major Android channels. Pea pods has 90,360 mobile assistants, 120,000 mobile assistants and 100,000 application treasures. There are also mobile app stores such as Xiaomi and Huawei. It is estimated that the download volume of pear video on Android should be around one million.

The ranking in the App Store is not bad. In the single ranking of news, it is basically within the top 20, and the total list is basically within 1000.

Baidu index is around 1000, and it can also be:

As an emerging app, this is really a good result. However, compared with the high investment, high-profile release and explosive video of pear video, such achievements are not successful.

Especially look at user activity. This is the total video ranking list on Pear Video app.(November 21):

They did not announce the broadcast volume, but published comments and praises. The hottest gun battle in northern Myanmar, with 31 comments and 75 praises. The second is Trump’s children’s education, with 11 comments and 19 praises. It should be noted that the release cycle of these two videos has exceeded one day, which has been fully disseminated.

Therefore, from the perspective of platform construction, pear video is really not hot.

Is it possible that pear video will become an important short video distribution platform in the future?

The possibility is slim.

The first is the user acquisition problem.

Today’s news clients, such as headlines, are too powerful, which are naturally suitable for the spread of information short videos, with a huge user base, mature user habits, and interest recommendation overwhelming manual editing.

The current situation is that pear video has published content in various channels such as today’s headlines and Netease News, and can be watched directly. Why should these users jump to the pear video app? How difficult it is to promote app now, I think everyone has feelings.

If pear video only publishes content in its own app, it may attract some loyal fans, such as Caixin app, but it is also doomed to a niche.

The second is the issue of entering the media.


Because of the traffic advantages of the news client and WeChat, it attracted a lot of self-media, created massive content for different segments of people, and formed a complete ecology. Nowadays, the prosperity of content mainly depends on self-media, and the essence is PGC, not UGC. Youku, the largest UGC video platform in China, is getting worse every day.

Attract these pear videos from the media? Why, traffic or money? Since the media are a bunch of thieves. To tell the truth, "The Old Driver is Coming" has given up some platforms with relatively small traffic, because it is meaningless, it is better to concentrate on making several big platforms; After three months on the line, 22 videos were released, with a total broadcast volume of 31.65 million, mainly supported by four or five platforms.

Although I don’t like pear video, I didn’t say: short video entrepreneurship only has the direction of content IP, and it must not be a platform.

There are other possibilities for short video platforms, such as Aauto Quicker, which is still growing, with extremely high user activity, and has formed an ecology: advertisers-anchors-fans, and everyone has their own needs.Aauto Quicker can be crushed by the giants, can be despised by many people, tenacious live to the present, by what? "Double-click 666", a culture has been formed on the platform, just like bilibili, which is very sticky.

It is also possible for short video platforms to cut into sub-sectors to avoid confrontation with giants such as news clients. Like the connotation paragraph, it is the same as today’s headline teacher. Although it was covered by the light of the headline, this year actually grew rapidly, especially after strengthening the short video. Insiders said that they already had 130 million downloads and 6.2 million daily jobs, and they had long since stopped taking Encyclopedia of Embarrassment and Sister Bestow as rivals.

The policeman in my circle of friends, the local tyrant in the WeChat group, and the little brother who gave me a haircut are all friends …

First appeared in Zhihu’s column "Not Public"If you don’t tell me, I’ll do it. App analysis, online celebrity economy and marketing experiments have attracted the attention of ten thousand people.